Annuity Education

Annuities vs. CDs — Which Is Better for Retirement Savings?

A straightforward comparison of annuities and bank CDs for conservative retirement savers.

If you are a CD buyer looking for better rates, a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) is worth comparing. MYGAs work similarly to CDs — you deposit a lump sum, lock in a rate for a set term, and your principal is guaranteed. But MYGAs typically offer higher rates and tax-deferred growth.

Annuity vs. CD — Full Comparison

FeatureMYGA AnnuityBank CD
Interest RateTypically higher (5.20–5.45% for MYGAs)Typically lower
Tax TreatmentTax-deferred growthInterest taxed annually
Principal SafetyGuaranteed by insurance company + state guarantyFDIC insured up to $250K
Contribution LimitsNo limit (non-qualified)No limit
Penalty-Free AccessTypically 10%/year free withdrawalVaries by bank
Early WithdrawalSurrender charge + IRS penalty if under 59½Early withdrawal penalty
Lifetime Income OptionYes — can convert to guaranteed lifetime incomeNo
Probate AvoidanceYes — passes directly to beneficiariesNo (goes through estate)

When a MYGA Makes More Sense Than a CD

  • You want a higher guaranteed rate
  • You want tax-deferred growth
  • You are saving for retirement (not short-term needs)
  • You want the option of lifetime income
  • You want to avoid probate for your beneficiaries
  • You have more than $250K to protect

Compare Annuity Rates vs. Your Current CD Rate

We'll show you what you could be earning with a MYGA vs. your current CD.

Your information is private and secure. No spam, ever.

Annuity vs. CD FAQs

See How a MYGA Compares to Your Current CD Rate

Get a free, side-by-side comparison of current MYGA rates vs. bank CD rates for your situation.